The L1 rule on GeM: lowest price, three manufacturers and preferences
What L1 means
L1 means "lowest one": the bidder or seller with the lowest price among those that meet the requirement. L2 is the next lowest, L3 the one after, and so on. At the other end, H1 is the highest-priced bidder. On GeM the L1 rule appears in two places: in L1 buying from the catalogue, and in the award of bids and reverse auctions.
L1 is never simply the cheapest listing on the portal. It is the lowest price among offers that meet the buyer's quality, specification and delivery needs. A cheaper product that fails the specification is not L1.
L1 buying: comparing at least three manufacturers
Rule 149(ii) of the General Financial Rules, as amended by the Department of Expenditure's office memorandum of 10 July 2024, allows direct online purchase over ₹50,000 and up to ₹10 lakh through "the GeM Seller having lowest price amongst the available sellers, of at least three different manufacturers" meeting the requisite quality, specification and delivery period.
GeM's General Terms and Conditions, version 1.29, explain how this works on the portal. The buyer first compares all product options that meet its requirement. The comparison must be made between products of at least three different manufacturers or OEMs. The buyer then orders from the lowest-priced seller.
Three practical consequences:
- Three manufacturers, not three sellers. Three resellers of the same brand do not make a valid L1 comparison.
- A specific brand needs PAC. If the buyer wants one OEM's product, it must use Proprietary Article Certificate buying, with its competent authority's approval.
- One offer is not enough. Where only one offer, or one seller, is available after filtering, the buyer should not select it, except under PAC.
The seller with the L1 offer has already accepted the order by keeping a live listing with stock. A seller who declines can face action under GeM's incident policy.
Reasonableness of price: tools buyers use
Choosing L1 does not end the buyer's duty. Rule 149 requires procuring authorities to certify that rates are reasonable. The GTC lists the data buyers can use:
| Check | What it shows |
|---|---|
| Last purchase price on GeM | Rates at which recent GeM orders were placed for the item |
| Department's own last purchase price | What the same office paid before |
| Prices on other e-commerce sites | Comparison prices shown by GeM's tools, where available |
| Discount over MRP | Whether the offer goes beyond the mandatory 10% discount |
The GTC adds that e-commerce prices give a broad idea only, since their terms may differ. If the GeM price looks unreasonable or substantially higher than e-commerce or last purchase prices, the buyer can run a bid or reverse auction to get a better rate. Bidding "should be considered as the preferred mode of procurement above ₹50,000".
L1 in bids and reverse auctions
In a bid, L1 is the technically qualified bidder with the lowest evaluated price. The GTC says evaluation is on the total all-inclusive landed price at the consignee's destination unless the additional terms say otherwise. In a BoQ bid, L1 is decided by the total of all line items.
In a reverse auction, L1 is the bidder with the lowest price when the auction closes, after all 15-minute extensions. The buyer still keeps the right to accept or reject any bid, including the lowest, or to annul the process.
If two or more acceptable bidders tie at the lowest price for goods, a forced reverse auction is held among all technically qualified bidders with 50% elimination. For services, a tie at the lowest allowed price is broken by GeM's random algorithm. During a reverse auction, bidders lower their prices live, and a lower bid in the last 15 minutes extends the closing time by another 15 minutes.
Make in India preference in RA
Under the Public Procurement (Preference to Make in India) Order, 2017, which the GTC cites as dated 19 July 2024 and amended from time to time, sellers declare the local content of their offer by self-certification when they bid. In GeM reverse auctions, an eligible Make in India seller quoting within 20% of a non-MII L1 is allowed into the RA under both elimination rules. After the RA, the buyer awards keeping the Make in India order in view.
The class of supplier matters. If a seller fails to meet the declared local content and drops from Class-I to Class-II or non-local, a penalty of up to 10% of contract value can be imposed. For contracts over ₹10 crore, the local content certificate must come from a cost or chartered accountant.
When L1 is not chosen
There are a few legitimate reasons the lowest price does not win:
- Technical rejection. The bid fails the specification, eligibility criteria or document requirements.
- Non-responsive price. A bid quoting nil charges, or one that puts price elements in the technical bid, is rejected.
- PAC buying. With a Proprietary Article Certificate approved under Rule 166 of GFR 2017, the buyer buys a specific make, after bidding where the value is over ₹50,000.
- Direct purchase. Up to ₹50,000, the buyer may choose a product other than the lowest-priced one with competent authority approval, recording its reasons.
- Preferences. An MSE or Make in India seller matching L1 may take a share of the order.
Worked examples
| Situation | Result |
|---|---|
| L1 buying for ₹6 lakh; three brands meet the spec at ₹5.6 lakh, ₹5.9 lakh and ₹6.2 lakh | Order goes to the ₹5.6 lakh seller |
| Same case, but all three offers are from resellers of one brand | Not a valid L1 comparison; the buyer needs three manufacturers, or PAC approval |
| Bid for ₹40 lakh; L1 is a large company at ₹36 lakh, an MSE quotes ₹40 lakh | The MSE is within 15% of L1, so it may supply up to 25% of the value by matching ₹36 lakh |
| Bid to RA with 50% elimination and 7 qualified bidders | L1 to L4 go to the RA, plus any eligible MSE within 15% or MII seller within 20% of L1 |
In the third example, ₹36 lakh plus 15% is ₹41.4 lakh, so the MSE's ₹40 lakh is inside the band.
Frequently asked questions
What does L1 mean on GeM?
The lowest-priced offer among those that meet the requirement, whether in L1 buying from the catalogue or in a bid or reverse auction.
What is the L1 buying limit on GeM?
Over ₹50,000 and up to ₹10 lakh, from 10 July 2024. Over ₹10 lakh, a bid or reverse auction is mandatory.
How many products must a buyer compare for L1?
Products of at least three different manufacturers or OEMs.
Can an MSE win if it is not L1?
Yes. An MSE within L1 + 15% can match the L1 price and supply up to 25% of the tender value, or the full supply if the item cannot be split.
Does the MSE preference apply to state government bids?
The policy binds central ministries, departments and CPSUs. State bodies follow their own policies, stated in the bid's terms.
Must the buyer always choose L1?
In L1 buying and bids, yes, among technically acceptable offers, subject to MSE and Make in India preferences and PAC rules.